Updated September 2026. Indianapolis has no shortage of places to get coffee, which means “best” comes down to more than a trendy drink or a single roast. A great coffee shop starts with fresh coffee, thoughtful preparation, consistent service, and an experience that makes sense for the customer.
At Command Coffee, we roast coffee in-house in Indianapolis and serve it at two cafés: Fall Creek on College Avenue and Monument Circle downtown. We also ship freshly roasted coffee for people brewing at home.
What Makes a Great Cup of Coffee?
Fresh Coffee
Coffee changes after roasting, which is why freshness matters. Roasting in-house gives us a direct connection between the coffees we buy, the way we roast them, and the way they taste in the café or at home.
Thoughtful Roasting
Different coffees are capable of very different flavors. Our goal is not to force every coffee into the same profile. We roast with sweetness, clarity, balance, and drinkability in mind, whether the coffee is destined for drip, espresso, or someone’s home brewer.
Good Brewing
Even excellent coffee can taste disappointing when the grind, water, ratio, or extraction is off. Good café coffee depends on both the roasted coffee and the consistency of the people and systems preparing it.
Command Coffee’s Indianapolis Cafés
Fall Creek Coffee Shop & Drive-Through
Our original café and roastery is at 2910 N College Avenue. Fall Creek offers both a lobby and drive-through and is located just south of the Indiana State Fairgrounds near Ivy Tech’s Indianapolis campus.
See Fall Creek hours and details.
Monument Circle Coffee Shop
Our downtown café is at 55 Monument Circle, Suite 59. It sits directly on Monument Circle and offers mobile ordering when you want to order ahead.
See Monument Circle hours and details.
What Can You Order?
Our café menu includes drip coffee, cold brew, espresso drinks, lattes, cappuccinos, cortados, tea, seasonal drinks, pastries, and grab-and-go food. Seasonal offerings change, so the current Command Coffee menu is the best source before you visit.
Fresh-Roasted Coffee at Home
Our online coffee lineup includes house blends, rotating single-origin coffees, decaf, and subscriptions. Because individual origins change with availability and seasonality, we keep the current lineup together in one place rather than relying on old blog recommendations.
Shop current Command Coffee coffees and subscriptions.
Finding Your Best Coffee in Indianapolis
The best coffee shop is ultimately the one that fits how you actually drink coffee—whether that means a drive-through before work, a downtown café, an espresso drink, or fresh beans at home. If you are in Indianapolis, we would love to make Command Coffee one of the places you try.